****
Perfectly built, but too calculated and cold towards the ending
I liked
this novel very much, until I came to the last part on New London , of which I am not really able to
digest the conclusion. And this inevitably has a negative influence on my overall
judgment.
As always Hamilton is a master at managing complex
plots in an elaborate backdrop and make many well developed characters interact
in it. In this sense, “The Nano Flower” is the link between its first
production set on Earth in the near future and the space opera of his later
books.
Although
the series is known as the Greg Mandel trilogy, Mandel has a secondary role in
this book, as he is on stage as much as the other characters, or even less than
them. I must say this disappointed me a bit, because I really like this
character, who in the previous books was undoubtedly the hero, and I expected
at least a most decisive role of him in the resolution of the story, which
however didn’t happen. The cornerstone of this novel is no doubt Julia Evans,
although she cannot be considered the protagonist either. More simply it can be
called a choral novel.
Less
investigative than the previous ones, which is not necessarily positive, and
more imaginative, although longer, this book is more fast-paced and engaging
than them, thanks to the always excellent prose of Hamilton .
I would
have given five stars, but I found the whole story of Royan, including the
ending, quite depressing. I could not, in any way, like his selfish choices
towards his family. His motives still don’t make sense to me. And likewise I
found Julia too cold in reacting to the dramatic conclusion of the story of
this character. I felt, in the behaviour of both, something deeply wrong in
terms of human emotions, which gave me the feeling that the ending was almost
worked out in the cold, without any involvement, losing all contact with the
humanity of the characters. And all this clashes with the way Hamilton had dug up to that point in their
mind and psychology.
I also have
difficulty to consider credible that a character as powerful as Julia Evans
really cares so much for the good of mankind and secondarily for her interests.
It is unrealistic to say the least, especially when compared with the far from
rosy future that is described in this trilogy.
Both
aspects have caused my suspension of disbelief to collapse. What a pity.
The Nano Flower on Amazon.
No comments:
Post a Comment